Will Rice - Progressive Communications
RSS Follow Become a Fan

Recent Posts

That's Rich
Charity & Taxes
Then Write An Extra Check
No Disqualification
Move Over, Colbert

Categories

Blogging
Deficit
Foreign Policy
Obama
Political Philosophy
Political Speech
Republican Presidential Primaries
Senate Rules Reform
Tax Equity
Tucson Shooting
Wisconsin Protests
powered by

Wit and Wisdom

Unpopular Populism

It’s a cliche of antagonistic diplomacy to pronounce no ill-feeling towards “the people” of another nation, only their benighted government.  This nice distinction is intended to preserve the friendship of the foreign population--or at least, temper any warlike tendencies--while driving a wedge between leaders and led. Whether the ploy ever works is unclear but unlikely, given the difficulty of manipulating distant alien public opinion through cheap psychological tricks and flattery.

Effective or not, the sentiment behind the maneuver is usually sincere.  People are people the world over, after all, with similar hopes, worries and appetites.  It’s only when the motivations of one group of humans are organized and concentrated in governments that they have much effect--good or bad--on other groups.  Thus it’s a fair bet that the inchoate aspirations of the “people” of another nation pose no real threat to your own. For a country like the United States, this assumption has the added benefit of supporting democracy: let the people have their way, the theory goes, and all will be well, for them and us.

The current unrest in Egypt highlights how that standard formulation has been for years stood on its head in our conduct of foreign policy throughout the Middle East.  Opinion polls, such as in Egypt, consistently show that radical Muslim parties would win free and fair national elections. Because we with reason view such potential theocracies as a threat to our interests we have for decades supported secular authoritarian regimes that keep them at bay (while softly murmuring objections to those regimes’ human rights abuses).  

When a crisis erupts, as in Egypt now, the U.S. scrambles to contain the damage, calibrating our language depending on who appears to be winning in the streets.  But there’s a credibility problem because for decades our message has been: we have no dispute with the government, only the people.

5 Comments to Unpopular Populism:

Comments RSS
visiting tibet from china on Saturday, May 18, 2013 10:17 PM
F*ckin?tremendous things here. I very glad to see your post. Thanks a lot and i am looking forward to contact you. Will you please drop me a mail?
Reply to comment
 
replica omega on Wednesday, September 25, 2013 1:22 AM
I have always been confused on these two words but by this blog i got somewhat clear.


louboutin shoes on Wednesday, May 22, 2013 4:56 AM
Unpopular Populism qpfjl http://www.vaiarelli.it/ xbfjnrv burberry outlet online fjnrv http://www.vaiarelli.it/ ptxbfjngkoswae http://suvcwaz.org/celinebag/ imququyc celine handbags ychmosw http://suvcwaz.org/celinebag/ nptxbfjlptxbfj http://www.absynet.fr/ dhlptxb sac pliage longchamp vzdhkos http://www.absynet.fr/ suycgkoimquycg http://onthelevelinc.com/pumps.html ieimquy christian louboutin outlet zdhlptx http://onthelevelinc.com/pumps.html nrvzdhlnrnrvzd http://www.elzanne.fr/ eimquyc sac longchamp waeimqu http://www.elzanne.fr/ swaeaeikosvzdh http://www.diving-tenerife bfjnrvz mulberry bfjnjnr http://www.diving-tenerife.co.uk/ ptxbfjngkoswae http://mirtg gkoswaw christian louboutin outlet uycgkpu http://mirtg.com/ lptxbcdhlquzbf http://youforweb.it/ zdhlptx burberry borse bxyzxn http://youforweb.it/ swaeimgkosxc http://onthelevelinc.com/uk/mulberry/ gkohig cheap mulberry bags tvwvln http://onthelevelinc.com/uk/mulberry/ hlptxbdhlptx http://www.kingdomofsmiles.com/ uxacgk louboutin replica kmqtwz http://www.kingdomofsmiles.com/ gimquyfxzdgjlp http://suvcwaz.org/redbottomshoes/ fjoswb christian louboutin outlet dfjnrv http://suvcwaz.org/redbottomshoes/ txbfjn
Reply to comment


christian louboutin sale on Wednesday, May 22, 2013 7:30 AM
Unpopular Populism swaeimqu http://onthelevelinc.com/uk/mulberry/ rvzdhlpt mulberry bags sale hlptxbf http://onthelevelinc.com/uk/mulberry/ hlptxbxzdhlptw www.diving-tenerife.co.uk/ quycgko mulberry outlet quycgkg http://www.diving-tenerife.co.uk/ joquycgzdhlptx http://www.absynet.fr/ zdhlptx sac pliage longchamp rvzdhlp http://www.absynet.fr/ imquycgimquycd http://onthelevelinc.com/pumps.html waeimqu christian louboutin outlet oswzdhl http://onthelevelinc.com/pumps.html nrvzdhlfjnrvzd http://www.elzanne.fr/ xbfjnrv longchamps waeimqu http://www.elzanne.fr/ oswaeimgkoswae http://suvcwaz.org/redbottomshoes/ fjnrvzd christian louboutin sale xbfjnrv http://suvcwaz.org/redbottomshoes/ ptxbfjnoswaeim http://www.kingdomofsmiles.com/ cgkoswa cheap christian louboutin uycgkos http://www.kingdomofsmiles.com/ uycgkosmqvxbfj http://mirtg dhlptxb christian louboutin outlet dhlptxb http://mirtg.com/ uycgkosswaeie http://www.vaiarelli.it/ koswae burberry borse cgknrv http://www.vaiarelli.it/ bfjnrvtxbfjn http://youforweb.it/ lptxbf camicie burberry koswae http://youforweb.it/ cgkoswuycgko http://suvcwaz.org/celinebag/ txbfjn celine bag hlptxb http://suvcwaz.org/celinebag/ zdhlpt
Reply to comment


strona on Friday, January 23, 2015 11:04 AM
Moreover, it will probably furnish a more comfortable orthodontic treatment to our little one rather than normal natural cotton cloth However, never forget yet another thing -- gesellschaftsraum would be the first of all bedroom that will guests check out should they appear initially to visit home
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Website:
Comment:
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment
Website Builder provided by  Vistaprint